Charles Tilly — Writings on Methodology

Introductory Essay to Charles Tilly’s Writings on Methodology

Introductory Essay to Charles Tilly’s Writings on Methodology

Introduction While Charles Tilly may be best known for his research of large scale social change and collective action in European history, he has also written extensively on research methodology. Over the years, roughly a quarter of his publications have concerned method, ranging from specific techniques to general considerations of logic, epistemology, and ontology. In his early methodological writings, Tilly spoke especially to social historians, urging them to embrace quantitative (formal) methods in historical analysis (Tilly 1972). Later, Tilly’s methodological writings focused more on the ontology of macro social change. In assembling a website of Tilly’s methodological contributions, our primary goal is to provide a convenient source where scholars can become acquainted with his methodological views on social research. Core… More »

User Guide

User Guide

The three categories make it convenient to search for articles that fall into a particular domain. To view a list of articles under a specific category click that category’s link in the right column.

Keywords are phrases in the description of the article to allow users to perform a more specific topical search of Tilly’s writings. The relevant keywords are: Anthropology, European History, Formal Methods, Historical Sociology, Invariant Modeling, Labor History, Political Contention, Social Mechanisms, Social Networks, Sociology, and Urban History. To view a list of all articles characterized by this keyword, type the keyword in the search box in the right column and press the search button.

History of and in Sociology

Historical Sociology

The article compares Pitirim Sorokin’s, George Homans’s, and Barrington Moore Jr.’s views of historical sociology. Sorokin favored what Tilly calls “Epochal Synthesis” in which a researcher crafts a grand historical scheme and then uses historical material to detect stages within that scheme. In Homans’ work,… More »

Three Visions of History and Theory

Historical Sociology

The article contrasts three current perspectives of how sociology and history interact.. In the “practical sense” perspective, exemplified by Burke’s History and Social Theory (2005), history is envisioned as the repository of human richness and theory as a set of tools that can be used… More »

Philosophies of History and Social Science

Historical Sociology

The article critically reviews William Sewell Jr.’s “Logics of History. Social Theory and Social Transformation” and Arthur Stinchcombe’s “The Logic of Social Research”. Tilly contends that Sewell’s book focuses exclusively on the relationship between history and social science, while Stinchcombe’s book, which emphasizes theories of… More »

Why and How History Matters

Social History, Political Contention

The article argues that all political analysis requires serious consideration of the historical context. Tilly outlines several reasons why history matters to political analysis: (a) political analysis makes assumptions about historical origins of phenomenon and time-place scope conditions; (b) some features of political processes occur… More »

It Depends

The article introduces the main topics covered in Tilly’s edited volume (with R. Goodin), The Oxford Handbook of Contextual Political Analysis. The primary objective of the volume is to demonstrate that acquiring systematic political knowledge requires analysts to get context “right”. The authors distinguish between three classes of contextual effects that impact the study of political processes: (1) the level of an analysts’ understanding of the political processes they are attempting to study, (2) the nature of evidence available for the empirical examination of specific political processes, and (3) the nature and context of the political processes themselves. Additionally, the authors review alternative approaches to political analysis, discuss the necessity of explanatory stories in political analysis, and detail the strategies used by current political science researchers to either control or correct for context.

More »

Afterword: Political Ethnography as Art and Science

Political Contention

The article briefly summarizes the benefits of using political ethnography over conventional social scientific methods. The primary benefits of this method are the researcher’s ability to closely observe social processes and develop more comprehensive insights. This benefit is critical to readers who, like Tilly, believe… More »

Repression, Mobilization, and Explanation

Social Mechanisms

The article argues that scholars who study mutual relations between repression and mobilization should focus on the classification of episodes into recurrent processes and invariant mechanisms and move away from trying to identify covering laws. More »

Social Boundary Mechanisms

Political Contention

The article proposes a set of mechanisms that precipitate and constitute social boundary change. Tilly defines social boundary change as the "contiguous zone of contrasting density, rapid transition, or separation between internally connected clusters of population or activity". Mechanisms that cause boundary change are identified… More »

Lullabies, Chorales, and Hurdy-Gurdy Tune

Historical Sociology

The article reviews the methodological choices historical sociologists confront when they do their research. Tilly organizes these choices into five categories: genre, ontology, explanatory logic, mechanisms, and practical procedures. The article describes what these categories entail in some detail and concludes with a set of… More »

Terror, Terrorism, Terrorists

Political Contention

The article addresses the use of terminology surrounding the phenomenon of terrorism. He defines terror as "the asymetric deployment of threats and violence against enemies using means that fall outside the forms of political struggle routinely operating within some current regime". He argues that social… More »

Observations of Social Processes and their Formal Representations

Formal Methods

The article outlines the advantages of formalisms, defined as the "explicit representation of a set of elements and of relations among them", in historical research. Formalisms, he writes, help researchers discipline their research inquiries from the outset and make it easier to discover alternative explanations.… More »

Rhetoric, Social History, and Contentious Politics: Reply to Critics

Political Contention, Social Mechanisms

The article advocates the continued efforts within the historical study of contentious politics to identify the robust mechanisms that appear in a wide variety of contentious episodes which will help to explain important similarities and differences among them. More »

Why Read the Classics?

Social Scientific Knowledge

The article describes how sociological classics positively influence current research. Tilly’s primary argument is that the classics provide “sources of justification” for contemporary arguments. The classics also commit researchers towards the cumulative goal of answering important questions, and identify the theoretical conversations in which researchers… More »

Sociological Resources for the Study of International Relations

The article identifies areas of sociological analysis that can benefit current research in the field of International Relations. The areas identified are: State formation War and revolution World Systems Boundaries, identities, and related social processes Migration Contentious politics Globalization More »

Event Catalogs as Theories

Formal Methods

The article describes one of Tilly’s favorite formal methodologies, the event catalog. The benefit of using event catalogs, defined as a set of descriptions of multiple social interactions collected from a delimited number of sources using a uniform procedure, is that it focuses the researchers… More »

Historical Analysis of Political Processes

Historical Sociology, Political Contention, Social Mechanisms

The article urges sociologists to renew their search for robust causal mechanisms and processes in history. It then outlines an analytical program that includes goals such as pursuing robust mechanisms and processes that make up large social phenomena, explaining puzzling features in historical episodes, explaining… More »

Historical Sociology

Historical Sociology

The article provides an overview of the subfield of Historical Sociology which he parses into four intellectual pursuits. The first pursuit is social criticism which aims to reconstruct of the past on the way to informing human choices in the present and future. The second… More »

Mechanisms in Political Processes

Social Mechanisms

The article defines his ontological view of the social world as a set of bounded episodes that are made up of a complex array of small recurrent social processes. He terms this the mechanism-view of the explanation of political processes where the main goal is… More »

Iron City Blues

Social Mechanisms

Tilly reviews "Fundamentalism, Sectarianism, and Revolution: the Jacobin Dimension of Modernity" by S.N. Eisenstadt. Tilly argues that research proposing to make civilizations and societies major actors within human history must indentify (1) the boundaries separating each unit and it population from other units, (2) the… More »

Errors, Durable and Otherwise

Explanation

The article contrasts the difference between strong and weak functionalist arguments. Strong functionalist arguments explain social phenomenon by their consequences for the system in which they occupy, whereas weak functionalist arguments claim that actors pursue certain ends by trying different means and adopt them to… More »

Jumbo Speaks

Historical Knowledge

Tilly reviews “The Sociology of Philosophies” by Randall Collins, an analysis of the formation philosophical thought over humanity’s entire literate history. Tilly cites methodological issues with Collins’ analysis (i.e. data selectivity issues, lack of economy in the presentation of data) and questions the plausibility and… More »

The Trouble with Stories

Social Scientific Knowledge

The article suggests that sociology's strongest insights do not take the form of standard stories - sequential, explanatory accounts of self-motivated human action - which are common in historical analysis. This is due to the limits of storytelling including: (1) its limited number of interacting… More »

A Grand Tour of Exotic Landes

Social History

The article reviews historian David Landes' sweeping comparison of successes and failures in economic growth, arguing against its long-term cultural determinism. More »

Wise Quacks

Social Mechanisms

The article advises social movement researchers to (1) define their work not as an explanation of social movements but as an explanation of contentious politics, (2) interrogate categories for variability within them, (3) search for causal mechanisms instead of universal patterns, and (4) recognize that… More »

Micro, Macro, or Megrim?

Social Networks

The article outlines the four main ontologies that social scientists have applied to social life. Phenomenological individualism which is the doctrine that individual consciousness is the primary or exclusive site of social life, methodological individualism which is the doctrine that assumes human individuals are the… More »

Means and Ends of Comparison in Macrosociology

Invariant Modeling

The article suggests that Big Case Comparison research is disappearing from the social sciences due to the difficulties expressed by John Stuart Mill, often credited with formulating the comparison method, who actually questioned the method of agreement/disagreement pertaining to human affairs. More »

James S. Coleman as a Guide to Social Research

The article argues that the program for social science outlined by James S. Coleman is misguided because it neglects to specify causal mechanisms, it promotes incomplete psychological reductionism, and advocates rational choice analysis which is ill equipped to explain many social processes. More »

What Good is Urban History?

Urban History

The article suggests that cties are an excellent natural laboratory in which to study the mechanisms which are tied to important macro processes such as social inequality. He urges urban historians to recognize this opportunity and ask the "big" questions in their research. More »

Macrosociology Past and Future

Invariant Modeling

The article suggests that "Big Case Comparison" research in macrosociology is ontologically inadequate due to the a priori assumption that macro events are distinctive and coherent units of analysis (misplaced concreteness). Further, it has lost its appeal due to the disintegration of autonomous states/societies/cultures. This… More »

To Explain Political Processes

Invariant Modeling, Political Contention, Social Mechanisms

The article critiques the method of invariant modeling of macro social processes. He claims that this practice leads researchers to focus on "improving the model" as opposed to understanding that the regularities between macrosociological processes do not operate in the form of recurrent structures and… More »

History and Sociological Imagining

Invariant Modeling

The article argues that one of the primary problems with invariant modeling in sociology is the assumption of monadism, that elementary units of social life are self contained monands that aggregate up to form society, that the social world consists of structures and processes that… More »

Softcore Solipsism

Historical Knowledge

The article critiques two books on 19th century English history of class formation discussing their focus on radical individualism, and categorizing them as works of "softcore solipsism". The philosophical doctrine of (hardcore) solipsism denies the possibility of knowledge beyong that of ones own experience. Softcore… More »

How (and What) Are Historians Doing?

Historical Method

The article compares history to other disciplines and outlines some of the major philosophical debates surrounding historical research. History stands out from other disciplines due to its: (1) insistence on time and place as fundamental principles of variation; (2) specialization according to time and place;… More »

History, Sociology and Dutch Collective Action

Historical Sociology

The article observes that the study of collective action is split in the social sciences and history between three factions: those that take the coherent society as the starting point of analysis, those who treat the individual as the fundamental social unit, and those that… More »

Misreading, Then Re-Reading, Nineteenth-Century Social Change

European History

The article argues that many of the sociological models of modernization in Europe in the 19th century are misleading due to their depiction of the past world as overly immobile, fragmented, agrarian, rural, but locally homogenous and integrated. Tilly offers the alternative view that social… More »

Future History

Historical Sociology

The article expresses an argument for sociology, as a field, to return to its historical roots in which social interaction and processes are properly rooted in time and space. This important because, as Tilly points out, social processes are inherently path-dependent whereby "every existing structure… More »

Formalization and Quantification in Historical Analysis

Formal Methods, Labor History

The article argues that formal methods will remain on the periphery of the field historical research until the major questions of the field change to ones that can be properly addressed by explicit models, system variation, or the comparison of many cases. This is because… More »

GBS + GCL = ?

Political Contention

The article proposes a study which looks at how the development of capitalism and power concentration affects how ordinary people contend for their interests. Drawing from the findings of two previous studies, the Great Britain Study (GBS) and the Geography of Contention in London (GCL),… More »

The Analysis of Popular Collective Action

Political Contention

The article critiques unitary actor models of popular collective action, claiming that collective action is largely a strategic interaction among several parties and follows a dynamic that no single-actor model can represent. Utilizing a brief analysis of the rural conflicts of 1830 in England, this… More »

Linkers, Diggers, and Glossers in Social History

The article describes how the field of social history is composed of three types of researchers: Linkers: those who look to compare social processes and mechanisms. Diggers: those who view history as a base where vital information about national politics can be found. Glossers: those… More »

The Tyranny of Here and Now

Historical Sociology

The article contends that sociological findings are oriented to a single time and place: Here and Now. To escape the tyranny of this boundary condition, sociologists focus on structures and processes that minimize constraints of time and place. Therefore, sociologists insist on explicit conceptualization, hypothesis… More »

Retrieving European Lives

European History, Formal Methods

The article argues that the central activity for the study of European social history is reconstructing ordinary people's experience of large structural changes. Formal methods for this task such as collective biographies have the disadvantage of missing critical elements of movements and being enormously time… More »

Neat Analyses of Untidy Processes

Labor History, Formal Methods

The article speculates about the impact of formal methods (e.g. collective biography) on the study of labor history. Formal methods have been used to answer many of the peripheral questions of the field but the core questions, such as fluctuations in the militancy or effectiveness… More »

The Old New Social History and the New Old Social History

Formal Methods

The article contrasts the impact of "The New Social History" of the 1960s which was based on applying statistical analysis to historical evidence, in light of the field's return to a more narrative-based analysis of historical events in the 1970s which he terms "The New… More »

A British View of American Strikes

Political Contention

A review of "Strikes in the United States 1881-1974" by P.K. Edwards. The book attempts to explain how and why the American strike picture has been altered during the enormous industrial and institutional changes of the past century. The review applauds the book for bringing… More »

Two Callings of Social History

Historical Method

The article argues that social history research can be segmented into retrospective and prospective callings. The retrospective calling looks at the current world and tries to figure out how it came into being and how it affected the everyday life of ordinary people. The prospective… More »

Historical Sociology

Historical Sociology

The article gives a brief history and definition of the field of Historical Sociology. He posits that sociology's shift back towards history is a result of the general dissatisfaction with its developmental models of large-scale social change. Sociology, Tilly writes, is clearly differentiated from history… More »

Anthropology, History, and the Annales

Anthropology

The article comments on the two main differences between the fields of anthropology and history. He argues that historians tend to be concerned with fixing action in time rather than space and anthropologists are concerned with fixing action in place rather than time. Additionally, historians… More »

Computers in Historical Research

Formal Methods

The article describes the effect of computers on historical analysis. He argues that computers reduce the time necessary for collecting and matching historical data, but that there is also an underlying danger. The increased ease in which researchers can make post hoc statements regarding spurious… More »

Quantification in History, as Seen from France

Formal Methods

The article argues that the rise of quantification in historical analysis is the result of: (1) the widespread adoption of the collective biography and (2) the arrival of historians trained in outside disciplines with analytic training and a desire to answer questions about long-run changes… More »

Methods for the Study of Collective Violence

Political Contention

The article discusses five major methodological problems plaguing the study of collective violence: (1) Problem of basic definition (2) Problem of biased enumeration (3) Problem of fragmentary documentation (4) Problem of multiple units of analysis (5) Problem of attaching violent action to its context More »

Anthropology on the Town

Anthropology

The article describes the methods used by urban sociologists for studying life in large cities. He argues that anthropological methods become important in this area after average data (i.e. census) became prevalent. Cases that deviated from the mean become more interesting and important. These methods… More »

In Defence of Jargon

Sociology

The article outlines three practices that separate sociologists from historians: (1) their insistence on explicit conceptualization; (2) their use of systematic comparison; (3) their attempts at objective verification. More »